Refining Capacity: Impending Glut or New Golden Age

In June of 2009 an article entitled “A Tsunami of Change Bearing Down on the Refining Industry” published by Roger Ihne of Deloitte, he warned that the US refining industry could be in for an extended period of overcapacity, low margins and utilization rates, and resultant low profitability.  He pointed to the recent decrease in domestic gasoline consumption that accompanied the 2008 price spike (to $150 bbl and $4 gal gasoline) and the financial crisis driven economic recession as evidence that Americans could reduce their fuel habit at a much faster rate than previously imagined. 

 Ihne also foresees a number of government mandates as further facilitating the downward trend in gasoline demand.  These included 1) Accelerated requirements for more fuel efficient vehicles 2) Mandated use of biofuels 3) A carbon emissions reduction system (i.e. Cap and Trade)  that will increase refined gasoline cost and thus further reduce demand.

The end result of rising gasoline prices and government mandates aiming to curb oil demand and promote biofuels and other renewables is forecast to result in 2030 gasoline demand that is down 13% from current levels.  Over this 20 year period Ihne predicted US refining utilization rates in the low 80% range and the current trend seems to be moving in his direction (see chart below). 

On the other side of the refining debate is EOR Energy Resources CEO Richard Chimblo who published a rebutal in the Oil and Gas Journal that argued that additional capacity will be needed over the next few decades.  He particularly challenges that assumption that biofuels will grow to a meaningful percentage of US fuel transport consumption because unsubsidized the industry remains “neither efficient nor economical”.  The energy invested for energy gained math indeed does not seem to add up for domestic corn based ethanol and distribution would require a whole new pipe system since ethanol can not use the same transmission pipes as gas or oil.He further argues global demand for refined gasoline should be increasing rapidly over this period as the supply of light crude oils is decreasing.  Therefore there is an opportunity for refineries able to process tar sand bitumen and other heavy oils, most of the reserves of which happened to be located in the western hemisphere.    

My take on the debate is that much of the outcome hinges on the US governments stance on carbon emission legislation.  Under a regime where intensive heavy oil processing becomes uneconomical due to its intensive carbon footprint, the US refining industry will certainly contract.  However, if technology or more accommodating carbon legislation allow investment in new refineries capable of meeting gasoline demand even after the days of light sweet crude there may be an opportunity for America to lead a new phase in the history of transport fuel refining.



Filed under Uncategorized

2 responses to “Refining Capacity: Impending Glut or New Golden Age

  1. 1353574|=|=

    The word “glut” makes me feel bloated.

  2. laowens87

    On December 23, 2009, a “Chilly Climate for Oil Refiners” by Jad Mouawad was published in the New York Times. In the article, Mouawad discussed the recent demise of the petroleum refinery industry in the United States and provided evidence that complimented the argument presented in “A Tsunami of Change Bearing Down on the Refining Industry”. Mouawad attributed the projected monotonic reduction in refinery capacity to the climate change policy objectives of the Obama Administration that focus on increasing in the dependence on alternative fuels and improving the fuel efficiency of automobiles. Based on the information provided in both articles, the petroleum refinery industry in the United States is clearly in trouble as it attempts to deal with the “impending glut” (“Refinery Capacity: Impending Glut or New Golden Age”, 2010).

    As refineries continue to shut down across the United States, what does the future hold for the refinery industry? American corporations with a financial stake in the petroleum refinery industry will face many challenges in the coming years, but future success will depend on their ability to diversify. Expanding gasoline markets in developing nations (such as China and India) create opportunities for companies to remain competitive in the petroleum refinery industry. However, the future leaders of the refinery industry in the United States will need to possess a portfolio with assets ranging from petroleum refineries to ethanol refineries to biofuel refineries.

    Petroleum refinery companies must take proactive measures in the downturn by investing in the processing of alternative forms of primary energy instead of taking a defensive position. As stated by Charles T. Drevna, “President of the National Petrochemical and Refiners Association,” “the industry is on its collective knees right now” (Mouawad, 2009). Valero Energy Corporation, the largest refiner in the United States, recognized the call to diversify and purchased several ethanol plants despite the shutdown of Valero Energy Corporation’s petroleum refinery in Delaware City. The recent investment decisions of Valero Energy Corporation serve as a model for other companies to emulate sooner rather than later. A long term vision is crucial for refiners.

    [1] Mouawad, J. (2009, December 23). Chilly Climate for Oil Refiners. Retrieved from New York Times website:

    [2] A Tsunami of Change Bearing Down on the Refining Industry . (2009, July 17). Retrieved from Deloitte website:

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s